NY charter schools’ success, Letters

Charter champion

The Post’s recent editorial provides yet more evidence of the superior performance of charter schools in New York (“Fresh Proof NY Needs More Charters,” Jan. 16).

When I was an undergraduate, I was fortunate to take a course taught by a professor who was an early advocate of charter schools, as well as educational vouchers for parents to use in private schools. The professor posed this question: Should parents or the government have the fundamental right — and corresponding responsibility — to provide for the education of children?

The answer reveals a great deal. If your answer is with the parents, then you are more likely to support charter schools and educational vouchers, because they give parents the financial ability to choose what is best for their kids. If your answer is the government, you accept “failing” public schools.

James E. Ciecka, Chicago, Ill.

Stuffed courts

Thank you for highlighting examples of all the frivolous litigation winding through our court system (“Crazy cases from bad to (vers)us,” Jan. 17).

Our courthouses have turned into a vehicle for preposterous claims and get-rich-quick schemes. In this particular case, a woman sued Geico, which insured her partner’s car, for contracting an STD.

Legislators should work to stem the proliferation of absurd and cynical tort claims by adopting the British “loser pays” rule. If litigants and their attorneys bring unsuccessful tort claims, they should be required to pay the costs incurred in defending those claims. Such a rule would force attorneys and potential clients to think long and hard before signing on to flimsy lawsuits.

Peter Janoff, Stamford, Conn.

‘Royaled out’

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle were reportedly disappointed with the recent Emmy results, which snubbed their Netflix series (“Meanwhile, Emmy-loser Sussex sulk,” Jan. 18).

The snub is likely due to a widespread case of Harry and Meghan fatigue. Like the strident, repetitive blather from talking heads on Election Day, most viewers are willing to watch and listen for only so long. Eventually, they’ll change the channel or turn off the television.

There are too many quality shows to choose from right now. The couple’s drama has become monotonous. It’s about as interesting as radio static.

Vincent Ruggiero, Scottsdale, Ariz.

Z is for Zombie

It would seem that the kids today have collectively turned their backs on the American Dream (“Today’s kids have no drive,” Jan. 18).

Getting a job and a driver’s license — benchmarks once considered a rite of passage for American teenagers — is no longer a priority for Gen Z.

Perhaps contemporary life has been too easy for them. Parental support, combined with services like Uber and DoorDash, has made the need for a job and license almost obsolete. Add to that the legalization of marijuana, virtual reality video games and AI, and you start to think the kids should really be called: Gen Z(ombies).

Jack Kaufman, Naples, Fla.

Crime critics

I was so sorry to read about the newsstand vendors getting robbed and assaulted in Manhattan (“Newsstand Nightmares,” Jan. 15).

I hope that the “defund the police” pundits read that story. They might then stop thinking they know more about fighting crime than the police.

John Francis Fox, Queens

Want to weigh in on today’s stories? Send your thoughts (along with your full name and city of residence) to letters@nypost.com. Letters are subject to editing for clarity, length, accuracy, and style.

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Meghan Markle wins defamation lawsuit against Samantha Markle

Meghan Markle has won the defamation lawsuit brought forward by her half-sister, Samantha Markle.

Samantha Markle, 58, sued the Duchess of Sussex in federal court in Florida for allegedly making “demonstrably false and malicious statements” about her to a world audience during her and Prince Harry’s bombshell March 2021 interview with Oprah Winfrey.

Samantha filed the $75,000 lawsuit after Meghan told Oprah that she grew up as an only child.

The comments subjected Samantha to “humiliation and hatred,” she claimed.

But on Thursday, a Florida judge didn’t see it that way and dismissed the lawsuit, saying Meghan’s remarks were opinions and “not capable of being proved false.”

“As a reasonable listener would understand it, Defendant merely expresses an opinion about her childhood and her relationship with her half-siblings,” US District Judge Charlene Edwards Honeywell wrote in her order.

“Thus, the Court finds that Defendant’s statement is not objectively verifiable or subject to empirical proof. Plaintiff cannot plausibly disprove Defendant’s opinion of her own childhood.”

Samantha, who shares a dad with the exiled royal, claimed Meghan “orchestrated the campaign to defame and destroy her sister’s and her father’s reputation and credibility in order to preserve and promote the false ‘rags-to-royalty’ narrative [Meghan] had fabricated about her life to the Royal Family and the worldwide media.”

Samantha’s lawyer Peter Ticktin told the court that Meghan got caught in a lie about her upbringing and decided to slam her half-sister and estranged father to cover it up, according to the Daily Mail.


Meghan Markle’s half-sister Samantha Markle.

“Why else is she putting her sister down? Why else is she putting her father down? Why else is she denying her family who has done nothing but good to her all her life?” Ticktin said. “She never had a problem with them at all.”

He said the “false narrative” put out by Meghan harmed his client.

Samantha also wanted Meghan to take back allegations she made against the royal family by claiming “Queen Elizabeth was not a racist” and “King Charles is not a racist.”


Samantha was suing Meghan for making “demonstrably false and malicious statements” and tainting her reputation.
Getty Images

Meghan’s lawyer, Michael Kump, however, said Samantha had no grounds to sue for defamation.

He said the claims made by Samantha and her lawyer were “quite frankly offensive to my client” and demanded the case be dismissed.

“Not every perceived slight ought to be litigated and that’s true here,” he said last month. “Plaintiff is taking issue with Meghan’s own impressions of her own childhood growing up but that’s not a proper subject matter for a court of law.”


Samantha Markle on Tucker Carlson Today.
@TuckerToday/Twitter

He added that the duchess and former “Suits” star has a right to voice opinions “and even criticize” under the First Amendment.

The estranged half-sisters had been at odds for years before the famous 2021 Oprah interview.

Meghan has repeatedly accused Samantha and their father Thomas of selling stories to the British tabloids.

For her part, Samantha has continued to fire shots at the duchess and brother-in-law Prince Harry as the couple continues putting out documentaries and memories.

Last month, she accused the Duke of Sussex of being “emotionally underdeveloped.”

“I don’t think he can think like an adult because I don’t think emotionally he is one,” she added.

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Gwyneth Paltrow’s Utah ski slope trial continues into week 2

The trial over Gwyneth Paltrow’s Utah ski slope debacle concluded its first week with the lifestyle guru testifying she thought she was being sexually assaulted during the 2016 encounter.

Dr. Terry Sanderson claims the “negligent collision” with Paltrow seven years ago at the high-end Deer Valley Resort in Utah left him brain-damaged.

Sanderson sued the Goop founder, and the wellness influencer fired back with a “symbolic” $1 countersuit. 

Paltrow and Sanderson’s loved ones have been called to testify in the Park City courtroom.

Sanderson, who previously tried to sue Paltrow for over $3 million, is expected to take the stand on Monday. 

Paltrow’s children with ex-husband, Coldplay frontman Chris Martin – Apple Martin, 18, and 16-year-old Moses Martin – are slated to testify in the coming days.

Her current husband, Brad Falchuk, is also expected to be called. 

The trial has grabbed headlines covering topics ranging from the star’s outfits to the media attention to emails from Sanderson claiming he was “famous.” 

Here are the top five moments in the trial so far. 

Paltrow takes stand, claims fear of sexual assault

The 50-year-old actress defiantly took the stand on Friday while dressed in black, with her long hair down.

“I was hit by Mr. Sanderson, and he was at fault,” she said.


“I was hit by Mr. Sanderson, and he was at fault,” Gwyneth Paltrow testified.
AP

Paltrow was skiing with her kids, who were 11 and 9 at the time, and Falchuk – then her new beau – and his children. 

She testified that she was skiing with an instructor who told her after the crash that he would exchange Paltrow’s information with Sanderson.

Paltrow said she left the crash scene to reunite with her children.


Paltrow claimed that during the crash she thought someone was trying to sexually assault her.
AP

Paltrow then described how she feared someone was trying to sexually assault her because someone had crashed into her and was “groaning and grunting in a very disturbing way.” 

“I was skiing and two skis came between my skis, forcing my legs apart, and then there was a body pressing against me,” she told the court. “And there was a very strange grunting noise. So, my brain was trying to make sense of what was happening.”

“My mind was going very, very quickly, and I was trying to ascertain what was happening,” she went on. She later added: “Our bodies were almost spooning. And I moved away quickly.”

Sanderson: ‘I’m famous’

Paltrow’s attorney revealed in his Tuesday opening statement that Sanderson, 76, emailed his daughters shortly after the crash and wrote, “I’m famous.” 

Sanderson, a 76-year-old retired optometrist from Salt Lake City, said he suffered broken ribs and a concussion that has left him permanently brain damaged. 


Terry Sanderson claims to have suffered broken ribs and a concussion that has left him permanently brain damaged. 
AP

Dr. Wendell Gibby describes an MRI showing the brain of Terry Sanderson.
AP

He allegedly sent the email hours after the crash, to which one of his daughters responded she could not believe the collision “was caught on GoPro,” Paltrow attorney Steve Owens told the court. 

Owens said the GoPro footage is now missing. 

Camera complaints

Owens griped Wednesday about the media presence covering Paltrow and cameras at times getting “in her face.” 

The attorney pointed at a camera in the courtroom on Wednesday as he whined about “a new camera pointed directly at my client.”


Paltrow shields her face with a blue notebook as she exits the courtroom, Tuesday.
AP

“This has been a problem, for instance reporters being in front of my client’s car, going out yesterday. Cameras in her face,” he went on. 

The judge ruled the cameras should instead remain pointed at the person talking. 

Tears in court

Sanderson became an “angry person” after the crash, and his behavioral changes have impacted his relationships with loved ones, including a granddaughter, his daughters testified. 

Shae Sanderson Herath, his 52-year-old daughter, described through tears how her father went from someone with a “zest for life” to a “very insecure” person who “doesn’t trust his brain anymore.” 


Shae Herath described how her father, Terry Sanderson, became an “angry person” after the crash.
AP

Herath went on to describe how her father’s demeanor changed so much that it has changed his relationship with her daughter, Sanderson’s granddaughter.

 “She doesn’t like my dad,” she said. “She doesn’t like him.” 

Lawyer apologizes for being an ‘ass’

Owens apologized on day 3 of the trial for a tense moment earlier in the trial, when he asked Sanderson’s daughter if she believed her sister was a liar. 

Polly Sanderson Grasham, another of Sandersons’ daughters, was on the stand when Owen questioned her repeatedly about one of her sisters’ allegations that their father was abusive. 


Paltrow’s attorney apologized to Polly Grasham for badgering her during earlier questioning.
AP

Grasham stopped short of calling her father abusive and instead said Sanderson had “relentlessly tried to mold” her sister, Jenny. Jenny was initially expected to testify but ultimately refused. 

Owen then asked if Grasham believed her Jenny was a liar, with the woman responding, “sometimes we experience events differently.” 

The attorney returned after a lunch break and acknowledged the terse questioning. 

“I need to apologize, I was being an ass earlier,” he said. “It was wrong for me to triangulate you, your dad, your sister, and your mom. I ask for your forgiveness.”

With Elizabeth Rosner and Ben Kessler

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Paulsboro, NJ victims warn East Palestine, Ohio train residents

Prepare for a long legal battle.

That’s what victims of a 2012 toxic train derailment in Paulsboro, New Jersey are warning residents of East Palestine — as the tiny Ohio town continues to grapple with a devastating spill that leaked the same harmful chemical as the disaster a decade earlier.

News of last month’s freight train derailment in East Palestine quickly triggered traumatic memories for those in Paulsboro where residents were exposed to a cloud of vinyl chloride after 180,000 pounds leaked from a ruptured Conrail-owned tanker car.

The victims, including some who are still struggling with health woes they say are linked to the chemical exposure, are now urging those in Ohio — where 1.1 million pounds of vinyl chloride leaked following a derailment — to seek out legal advice so they can’t be ripped off by rail company, Norfolk Southern, when it comes to possible compensation.

“My heart goes out to those people,” Cassandra Clark, 54, told The Post this week.They have every right to be afraid of what’s going on.”


Walt Stevenson and his wife Irma were exposed to the toxic fumes in Paulsboro, New Jersey in 2012 because they live just 50 yards from where the train derailed.
Joe Lamberti for NY Post

“Make sure you’ve got lawyers, because I’m telling you, I don’t think they [Norfolk Southern] really care,” she continued. “We had a class action lawsuit, but you don’t really get anything from it. I can’t even remember the amount, but it was book money for my daughter for the first semester. It was nothing.”

In the aftermath of the Paulsboro ordeal, multiple class action lawsuits were filed on behalf of first responders and the hundreds of local residents who lived or worked near the site of the Nov. 30, 2012 derailment.

But some residents claim the rail company paid them off with “chump change” compensation to prevent them from seeking more cash if they developed serious health ailments down the line, including cancers.


Cassandra Clark, 54, said her young son had bouts of unexplained vomiting and diarrhea in the aftermath of the 2012 derailment.
Joe Lamberti for NY Post

“People signed letters to get money, but they waived all their rights,” said Paulsboro mayor Gary Stevenson, who was the deputy fire chief in 2012 when the derailment occurred.

“My advice to the [Ohio] residents is understand what you’re singing. You might be signing your life and health away if you do that.” 

Exposure to vinyl chloride – a carcinogenic – has already been linked to liver, brain and lung cancers, according to the National Cancer Institute.

The mayor, who lived less than 100 yards from where the train derailed, said he hadn’t heard of anyone being diagnosed with cancer and blaming it on the Paulsboro incident.


Residents in Paulsboro, NJ were exposed to a cloud of vinyl chloride after it leaked from a ruptured a Conrail-owned tanker car when it derailed on Nov. 30, 2012.
AP

Still, he said he gets regular medical testing because of his exposure and the unknown long-term health effects which could take many years to emerge.

“I went to a Philadelphia doctor for years after that, and he said, ‘Gary, you won’t see illness right away. It might take 20 years.’ It’s the same thing as people who work with asbestos and get mesothelioma years later,” Stevenson said.

“Up this point I’ve gotten blood tests regularly for my liver count. My numbers are good. But he said that would happen.” 

In East Palestine, residents have raised fears about the safety of the air and drinking water after officials carried out a controlled burn of vinyl chloride and other toxic materials in the wake of the Feb. 3 derailment.

The burn, which officials said was to avoid an explosion, sent plumes of smoke into the air and contaminated at least 4,500 cubic yards of soil and 1.5 million gallons of water, Northfolk Southern said on Monday.  

Stevenson said he knows the feeling of fear all too well.


In the aftermath, multiple class action lawsuits were filed on behalf of first responders and the hundreds of local residents who lived or worked near the Paulsboro site.
AP

“And trust me, the stigma will stay around. People say, ‘It’s still in the air, it’s still in the water, it’s still in the ground.’ Believe me, that stigma will stick around for quite a few years, I know that for a fact,” he said.

Mom-of-two Jacqui Benjamin is convinced her sons — Julian, now 15, and Dorian, now 10 — suffer from ongoing respiratory issues after breathing in the toxic fumes the day of the derailment.

“When the train derailed, this mist of chemicals engulfed all of Paulsboro and everybody breathed that in,” the 39-year-old recalled.

“When it happened, they both were vomiting like crazy. The next week it was the wheezing. We went outside, which we shouldn’t have done, and everyone but I developed asthma.”

She said her eldest still needs an inhaler if he exercises or overexerts himself.

The mom recalled getting compensation from the rail company, but described it as nothing more than “chump change” and a “slap in the face.”

“There’s a connection and it doesn’t want to be acknowledged that these kids have respiratory issues because of the chemicals. It’s just horrible,” she said.

“It’s sad that this is continuing to happen. I feel bad for them [in Ohio] because I know the trauma that the chemicals bring to a family. We experienced that and it’s the kids I’m worried about.”

Kristen Pickel said her late husband, Ronald Morris, who died in a motorcycle crash two years ago, suffered a deluge of ailments after driving through the chemical fog the day of the derailment.

“He was driving through Paulsboro to get to a job and he couldn’t see. It just overcame the vehicle. He was in the fog until he could get out of it,” Pickel, 50, said.

“It affected everything — his body, his state of mind. He wasn’t the same after.  He was very sick, kept going back and forth to the emergency room. He went through bouts of depression. Every morning he would throw up. He started drinking.”


Irma Stevenson and her husband Walt still live 50 yards from where the train derailed more than a decade ago.
Joe Lamberti for NY Post

She said the symptoms started immediately – and then the anxiety of “what’s going to happen to me?” set in.

“Doctors denied there was anything seriously wrong with him,” Pickel said.

Of the East Palestine ordeal, Pickel warned residents there that it would be “life changing.”

“These people are seriously going to have a long road because it’s not good. They just burned that stuff and let everyone breathe it in,” she said. “And if any of them try to sue, they’re going to get nothing. That’s what happened to us — we sued and we lost, because Conrail has powerful lawyers.”

Cassandra Clark’s son, who was only five or six at the time, had vomiting and diarrhea in the aftermath of the derailment.

“I remember it like it was yesterday. My son had been outside playing before school, and that particular day he got really sick,” she said. “It was really bad. He had never done that ever before or again. We hadn’t even heard about the train derailment yet, so we didn’t know what was going on.

“My daughter had walked to school, and had walked through the fumes. When she came home she just slept all day long, just slept, which was very out of character for her.”

Her son later developed hypothyroidism, which caused substantial weight gain and required medication — and Clarke suspects the toxic chemicals are the cause because thyroid trouble doesn’t run in her family. 

“It was a scary time. Of course you’re thinking the worst. Your son develops a thyroid problem and you’re like, where did this come from?” she said.

“You question whether this is something that’s going to reappear later in life. I think about my daughter — is something going to go wrong when it’s time to have children? You think about all that.” 


The Feb. 3 derailment in East Palestine, Ohio has sparked fears about the safety of water and air in the area.
AP

The mayor’s parents, Irma and Walt Stevenson, live 50 yards from where the train derailed.

Irma, 83, said trains would come by their house regularly and they never thought twice about what they were actually carrying prior to the incident.

“I was a nurse and I knew about chemicals, but I didn’t understand what the vinyl chloride was. I didn’t know what it was doing to my town,” Irma said.

“Being a nurse, I asked about possible health outcomes — brain cancer, liver cancer. How much did we breathe in that day? We were right here. My husband was in the fog, and it looked like the fog was coming up from the ground. Was this going to shorten our lives?”

She called on the federal government to crack down on regulating the rail industry in the wake of East Palestine, adding that the latest incident “breaks my heart.”

“The rail is supposed to have regulations, but are they followed? Are they fortifying the tank cars? Are they really doing inspections on the tracks? We had all these politicians coming promising to pass laws for this, for that. None of it happened,” Irma said.

 

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Wayne Ivey sued for ‘Wheel of Fugitive’ videos by David Gay

A man has filed a defamation lawsuit against a Florida sheriff who posts weekly “Wheel of Fugitive” videos on social media, saying that he wasn’t a fugitive when his name and image appeared several times in 2021 in the sheriff’s posts inspired by the long-running TV game show “Wheel of Fortune.”

Because of the sheriff’s posts, David Gay lost a job and suffered emotional distress, according to the lawsuit seeking more than $50,000 in damages. The lawsuit was filed last week in state court in Brevard County, along Florida’s Space Coast.

Gay’s prospective boss called him as he was driving to his first day of work and told him not to bother showing up as he had seen Brevard County Sheriff Wayne Ivey’s “Wheel of Fugitive” videos, the lawsuit said.

A spokesman for the sheriff’s office on Monday didn’t respond to an emailed inquiry seeking comment about the lawsuit.

In the videos posted to social media, Ivey spins a wheel with photos of what are described as 10 of the county’s most wanted fugitives.


Florida man David Gay is suing Sheriff Wayne Ivey for defamation after he was featured on Ivey’s “Wheel of Fugitives” when he wasn’t a fugitive.
AP

“Everybody watches it. Even the fugitives watch it” to see who becomes “fugitive of the week,” The Associated Press reported Ivey said.

Gay was involved in the court system for an undisclosed offense and was sentenced in November 2020 to three years of probation for a withhold of adjudication, a special sentence in which a defendant is not formally convicted of an offense, the lawsuit said.

Gay was taken into custody for violation of probation in January 2021 after he had been arrested several weeks earlier on a misdemeanor domestic battery charge. He says he believed his father had gotten into a physical altercation with his mother, and the case was dismissed eventually.

However, while Gay was in jail for the violation of probation arrest, Ivey said in a “Wheel of Fugitive” video that Gay was a fugitive, when in reality he was already in the Brevard County Jail, according to the lawsuit.

Gay was featured in three more episodes of “Wheel of Fugitive,” including on the day after he was sentenced to probation under the same terms that previously had been imposed and was released from custody, the lawsuit said.

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Suing Big Guns and Big Oil is just cynical political posturing

Buffalo Mayor Byron Brown announced last week that the Queen City had filed a “first of its kind” lawsuit targeting and blaming firearms manufacturers for the rising gun violence there. It’s not remotely the first, despite invoking a new “public nuisance” state law, and it’ll fail: Suits against Big Guns over crime, like those targeting Big Oil over climate, are just lawyer-enriching, and posturing-pol-promoting, bunk.

“The City of Buffalo is not going to let these gun industry members continue to flood our city with illegally possessed guns. We must hold them accountable,” Brown declared of the case against such gunmakers as Beretta, Smith & Wesson, etc., as well as distributors and local gun shops — plus, ghost-gun retailers like Polymer 80.

Maybe there’s a case against the ghost-gun crew, but all the other targets have weathered similar litigation before, starting in the ’90s. As long as the defendants obey the laws on serial numbers, background checks and so on, they’re not liable for third parties’ illegal use of their products.

The lawsuit blames gun manufacturers for the high number of illegal guns in Buffalo.
Corbis via Getty Images

Blame racist gunman Payton Gendron, not the gun industry, for the Tops Supermarket massacre. Local thugs and gangbangers are responsible for the terrible street violence in Buffalo and urban areas across New York.

Brown, like many pols before him, is trying to dodge his real duty. Lawyers are eyeing fees, or in some cases just hoping friendly judges will ignore the law to help them shut down the “evil” industry.

It’s much the same with litigation pretending that Big Oil has deceived the public about carbon fuels and climate change. Suit after suit has failed because the evidence just isn’t there — which hasn’t stopped New Jersey from filing a new suit because its politicians want to posture.

Reality check: Oil’s used precisely as intended to run our cars, heat our homes and keep the lights on. Lacking practical alternatives, society has chosen the emissions despite environmental costs. (By the way, global coal-burning rose this year, for the same reason.)

And while some petro-companies have questioned some claims of the anti-carbon lobby, they haven’t lied about what’s known, or even about what their private research has found.

Again, the hope here is that ideology will triumph in the courts where it hasn’t when it comes to writing laws. Lawyers get some work, politicians get to wax indignant — and they can all hope for a windfall if enough judges play along.

It’s not a bold struggle for justice; it’s a racket.

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Snapchat co-founder Reggie Brown accused of running amok in swanky gated community

The one-time tech visionary who invented Snapchat’s disappearing-photos feature vanished from the public eye after a nasty legal battle with his co-founders — and has since been accused of running amok in a swanky gated community, The Post has learned.

Reggie Brown, who co-founded Snapchat with Evan Spiegel and Bobby Murphy while the trio were hard-partying undergraduates at Stanford University, was pushed out of the company a decade ago. While Spiegel and Murphy became billionaires when Snap Inc. went public, Brown largely dropped off the map after winning a $157.5 million cash settlement from Snapchat in 2014 — when he was just 24 years old.

Now, a series of police reports, exclusively obtained by The Post through the Freedom of Information Act, shed light on the rejected inventor’s allegedly troubled life since he was ousted from Snapchat — despite his key role in creating the wildly popular social network — and returned to his native South Carolina.

The documents include allegations that Brown “swatted” a police officer after recklessly driving a Bentley luxury sedan during a reported music video shoot. He later became locked in an increasingly bizarre feud with his elderly next-door neighbors, who accused Brown of damaging their lawn with his car, using his large dog to intimidate them and even grabbing his crotch in front of their grandchildren, according to Columbia Police Department reports.

Brown had a series of run-ins with Columbia, SC police, records show.
AP

The Snapchat co-founder’s alleged behavior sparked outrage among residents of his close-knit neighborhood in Columbia. When police officers prepared to arrest Brown, they found out that he had left the state.

Brown and his family could not be reached directly for comment. Two attorneys who represented him in his litigation against Snapchat — James Lee and K. Luan Tran — did not respond to repeated requests for comment. A third attorney who previously worked for Brown, Ray Mandlekar, declined to comment.

Brown reportedly crashed a black Rolls Royce SUV into his subdivision’s security gate.
Google Maps

‘Filming a music video’

Brown’s first documented run-in with South Carolina cops was in December 2020 in the Kings Grant gated community, where he had lived since at least 2018 when he paid $890,000 for a five-bedroom, 6,900-square-foot mansion, according to property records.

On Dec. 10, a Kings Grant security guard told local cops that day that Brown had crashed a black Rolls Royce SUV into the subdivision’s security gate, according to police records. Police responded but left the scene without speaking to Brown.

The following day, police responded again after a neighbor complained about Brown allegedly recklessly driving another car — this time a four-door Bentley sedan. The neighbor also griped that Brown and his friends were “filming a music video” at the community center, which features a pool, playground and clubhouse.

Brown held a raucous music video shoot at the Kings Grant community center, according to police records.
Facebook/King’s Grant on the Ash

When an officer arrived, Brown was sitting in his Bentley outside the clubhouse and refused to roll down the window, according to the police report.

“I observed Mr. Brown to have a glassed over look upon his face and to have dilated pupils,” the officer wrote.

A man who was participating in the shoot then approached the police officer and explained that Brown had invited him there to film a music video, according to the police report. As the cop was speaking with the man, the Snapchat co-founder’s mother arrived, according to the report.

A section of the Columbia Police Department report on Brown’s alleged music video shoot.

Brown then stepped out of his Bentley and “aggressively lunged” at the neighbor who had originally called the police, according to the report. When the police officer tried to separate the pair, Brown allegedly “swatted” the cop’s arm away, leading the cop to put him in handcuffs.

Brown’s father and more neighbors then showed up, the police wrote, adding that “the scene quickly escalated and the [responding officer] requested additional units to maintain control.”

The officer then asked Brown to perform a field sobriety test. Brown agreed, according to the report, and passed the test. The police officer took off his handcuffs and released him. It would be nearly a year before his next run-in with the law.

Brown (left), with fellow Snapchat co-founders Bobby Murphy (center) and Evan Spiegel (right).
LA County Superior Court

‘A million-dollar idea’

Brown’s Snapchat story began in 2011, when he was smoking marijuana with his Stanford University fraternity brothers, according to the book “How to Turn Down a Billion Dollars,” by Billy Gallagher.

Brown, then a junior in college, mused that a disappearing images app would make sexting with girls easier — then rushed down the hall to see his friend Evan Spiegel, with whom he often threw Red Bull and vodka-fueled parties, according to the book.

“That’s a million-dollar idea!” Spiegel responded.

Brown and Spiegel then brought in Bobby Murphy, who wrote the code for a basic version of the app. In the summer of 2011, the trio moved into Spiegel’s father’s house in Los Angeles to work on the app.

But Brown’s relentless partying reportedly alienated Spiegel and Murphy, who were concerned he was more focused on going out than working, according to the book.

Following a series of arguments, Spiegel and Murphy locked Brown out of the startup’s accounts just months after Snapchat had launched.

While Snapchat soared in popularity, Brown sued Spiegel and Murphy in 2013, claiming that he rightfully owned 20% of the company. Spiegel’s response was brutal.

Evan Spiegel and Bobby Murphy ousted Reggie Brown from Snapchat in 2011, leading to a costly legal battle.
AFP/Getty Images

“I regret inviting him into my house,” Spiegel said of Brown during his deposition in the suit, which was leaked to Business Insider. “I regret spending that time with him at my house. I regret giving him so many chances. He exploited my attempts at generosity . . . the generosity was giving Reggie an opportunity to work on something like this.”

Still, Spiegel conceded, “Reggie may deserve something for some of his contributions.”

At the same time Brown was fighting Spiegel and Murphy in court, he completed a 10-month master’s degree program in management studies at Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business and graduated in May 2014, according to Gallagher’s book. He reportedly did not tell his classmates about his time at the company.

In September of 2014, Snapchat finally agreed to pay Brown $157.5 million in a cash settlement that included a gag order banning him from ever speaking publicly about the company.

Snapchat also released a statement that month acknowledging that Brown “originally came up with the idea of creating an application for sending disappearing picture messages” — but it buried the news from the tech press by publishing the release immediately before Apple’s iPhone 6 and Apple Watch launch event.

Brown’s former home in Kings Grant, where he allegedly engaged in a bizarre feud with his neighbors.
MLS

‘Mocking grandchildren’

Last November — nearly a year after Brown’s confrontation with neighbors and cops during the music video incident — a police officer knocked on the door of his mansion. Brown refused to let the officer inside, but cracked the door open a few inches to talk, according to a police report. It was two days after Thanksgiving.

The officer was there to confront Brown about what his neighbors said was an escalating harassment campaign they claimed he had waged against them.

Brown, the neighbors claimed, had damaged his neighbors’ lawn by driving his vehicle through it. He was also accused of shining his vehicle’s headlights into their bedroom windows and setting off his car alarm in the middle of the night to aggravate them, according to the police report.

In addition, neighbors accused Brown of walking up and down the street in front of his neighbor’s house while “making remarks to his family,” “mocking his grandchildren” and “making hand gestures,” the police report said.

Brown denied driving his vehicle in his neighbor’s lawn, entering their property or interacting or speaking with anyone while walking in front of their property, according to the report. He allegedly responded by claiming to the police officer that the neighbor had stolen half an acre of land from him and killed his palm trees.

“Mr. Brown stated [that the neighbor] has been pouring gasoline and oil down palm trees on his side of the property line which has turned them pink and killed them,” the report reads. “He stated [he] had video footage on his phone of the incident but told me he was not going to show me.” 

Brown reportedly added that his neighbor’s actions could be considered domestic terrorism and said he was considering calling the FBI. He said he was considering having his neighbor hauled away to Alvin S. Glenn Detention Center, a prison on the outskirts of Columbia, the police report says. 

The police officer told Brown that his neighbors had asked him to stop contacting them, then left, according to the report.

Brown accused his neighbors of stealing his property and killing his palm trees, according to a police report.
MLS

Arrest warrant

Shortly after the police officer left Brown’s residence, Brown’s neighbor called again to report a civil disturbance. The neighbor told police that — minutes after the first police officer had left — Brown walked onto his property and “began using profanity and antagonizing him.”

Brown then allegedly walked back to the border between their two yards, where he continued yelling “derogatory terms” at his neighbor and his grandchildren.

“Brown then grabbed his crotch toward him and his grandchildren,” the police report reads.

The neighbor also detailed more previous alleged incidents involving Brown. He said that Brown intimidated him with a Belgian Malinois dog that he had trained to respond to German commands, according to the report.

“Mr. Brown will command the dog to bark at him, and aggressively charge at him,” the neighbor told police.

Brown’s neighbors claimed that he intimidated them with a Belgian Malinois dog that he had trained to respond to German commands, according to police records.
Getty Images/iStockphoto

The neighbor also described a past incident in which Brown allegedly interrupted a dinner party. The neighbor and his family were entertaining guests on their front porch when Brown drove into his driveway, got out of his vehicle and “started making derogatory comments to his family and guest,” forcing everyone to go inside, according to the report. 

“He and his family are afraid for their wellbeing due to the fact that Mr. Brown’s behavior had gotten more aggressive over time,” the police report reads. 

When the police officer arrived at Brown’s house in response to the call, the officer said he saw Snapchat co-founder yelling at the neighbor from the back window of his house. The officer tried to speak with Brown, but he reportedly refused to come to the door. 

Four days after the last dust-up, seven police officers showed up at Brown’s house and knocked on his door. They were carrying an arrest warrant for his arrest on a charge of first degree harassment.

A section of a police report about Brown allegedly harassing his neighbors.

No one answered the door, so the officers reportedly went to Brown’s parents’ house nearby. Brown’s brother answered the door and allegedly said that Brown had left South Carolina for another state.

According to the police report, Brown’s father then reportedly arrived and explained that Brown had just been dropped off at an out-of-state mental health rehabilitation center. The center charges $58,000 for a minimum 20-day stay.

The neighbors appear to have since dropped the charges against Brown. They did not respond to multiple requests for comment for this story.

Snapchat’s 2017 initial public offering made Evan Spiegel and Bobby Murphy multi-billionaires in their twenties.
REUTERS

‘Vanished’

When Snapchat went public in 2017, the Los Angeles Times noted that the company’s mysterious third founder had “vanished from public life.”

The IPO made both both Spiegel and Murphy multi-billionaires in their twenties. If Brown had settled his lawsuit in exchange for Snapchat shares instead of cash, he too could have become a billionaire.

Even with Snapchat shares down 80% so far this year, a 20% stake in the company would be worth more than $3 billion.

In August of this year, Spiegel and his supermodel wife Miranda Kerr paid $145 million for an estate across the street from the Playboy mansion, Dirt.com reported in August. Combined with a $30 million villa Spiegel and Kerr maintain in Paris, the value of the Snapchat CEO’s real estate holdings is higher than the entire cash settlement received by Brown.

Meanwhile, the other Snapchat co-founder, Bobby Murphy, reportedly owns at least nine multimillion-dollar properties in Los Angeles worth a collective $60 million.

Murphy and Spiegel are both worth more than $2 billion each, according to Forbes.

A little over a month after Brown allegedly went to rehab, he sold his house on Jan. 11, 2022 for $1.04 million, property records show. It’s unclear where he currently lives. 

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Landlord sues White Horse Tavern for $640K in back rent

One of New York City’s oldest watering holes is in hot water. 

The West Village’s White Horse Tavern, which proudly claims to be “the second oldest pub in New York City,” is allegedly experiencing a problem as old as the Big Apple: Being late on rent — and a lot of it. 

Owner Eytan Sugarman allegedly owes more than $650,000 in unpaid rent for the 567 Hudson St. venue, landlord Steve Croman claims in a lawsuit filed Thursday in Manhattan Supreme Court. 

The debt traces back to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, when Sugarman began inconsistently paying the $41,500 he owes a month for the 142-year-old corner location (which is entirely separate from the 89-year-old White Horse Tavern located in the Financial District), Crain’s reported. The situation has come about despite Sugarman collecting $437,840 in federal Paycheck Protection Program funds in the summer of 2020 — money intended for the protection of 18 jobs at the establishment, which has either been forgiven or paid back, the publication reported.

The bar’s landlord sued the tenant for back rent and an additional $15,000 in legal fees.
Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images
The White Horse is among the oldest bars in the city.
Education Images/Universal Image

Croman was at one point more supportive of the saloon’s continued existence, granting Sugarman a monthly concession for half his rent for 18 months, the Real Deal reported. In August, that changed, and Croman demanded Sugarman repay the 18 months of concessions.

The suit also demands Sugarman pay a minimum of $15,000 in legal fees — in addition to the rent debt. However, the Real Deal notes, citing court documents, that Sugarman had issues paying rent in the early months of his tenancy; he signed a 15-year lease in March 2019. That April, Sugarman closed the bar for a month for renovations, which reportedly cost $1 million — and late payments allegedly began that August. By the New York arrival of COVID, there were allegedly already $11,500 in fees.

White Horse Tavern did not immediately return The Post’s request for comment.

The suit represents a turning of the tables for Croman, who spent eight months in prison for crimes involving mortgage and tax fraud in 2017, and also previously settled for $8 million after a federal civil suit found him liable for harassing rent-regulated tenants, Crain’s reported. 

Croman purchased the White Horse for $13.7 million in April 2019, not long after getting out of prison. The mixed-use property also has two residential apartments.

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Facebook parent company settles Cambridge Analytica lawsuit

Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, has settled a lawsuit filed against it in the wake of revelations that the company fed data from millions of users to Cambridge Analytica, a research firm which supported Donald Trump in the 2016 presidential election.

Filings in San Francisco federal court requested a 60-day stay of the action while lawyers finalize the settlement.
The Asahi Shimbun via Getty Images

The terms of the settlement were not disclosed but filings in San Francisco federal court requested a 60-day stay of the action while lawyers finalize the settlement, suggesting more details could emerge in late October.

Both Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg and his former top deputy Sheryl Sandberg would have faced hours of grueling deposition had the case gone forward.

The case emerged after Cambridge Analytica, a firm with ties to former Trump campaign strategist Steve Bannon, paid a Facebook app developer to receive access to personal data of 87 million Facebook users — which Cambridge than used to better place targeted political ads in support of Trump, who went on to win the 2016 election.

The lawsuit, which had sought certification as a class action representing all Facebook users, maintained that the privacy breach proved Facebook is a “data broker and surveillance firm,” as well as a social network.

With Post Wires

Check out our Latest News and Follow us at Facebook

Original Source

Exit mobile version