Balsam Hill artificial Christmas trees: My honest review

Growing up, the Christmas tree was one of my family’s most important parts of our Christmas tradition. It wasn’t until we successfully sourced and collectively erected our aromatic conifer that the holiday season could officially start.

Whether it was venturing out to chop down our own, heading to the grocery store parking lot to pick the perfect specimen, to even New York City Christmas tree trips to my local bodega to shell out a premium price to the tree farmers-cum-street vendors who set up shop alongside the sidewalk – if there isn’t a decked out Christmas tree in my living room, no amount of Christmas lights, garland, carols, nutcrackers or Santas can make it truly feel like Christmas. So you can imagine where this is going…this is a Balsam Hill Christmas tree review, after all.

RELATED: Best Christmas tree toppers for every style in the holiday season

With a neverending list of new household tasks, the thought of hunting a tree, keeping it watered, keeping the dogs out of it, cleaning up after it, and taking it all down doesn’t elicit the same feelings of joy it used to. Now, I just want it done.

For most of my years, I was adamantly against anything that would fall under the guise of an artificial Christmas tree. But here’s the thing – these days, I get to traverse tree farms with my nieces and travel more for the holidays than I ever did as a kid. Plus, let’s be honest; I’m just tired. Who can relate?

---

So, this year, I decided to test-drive an artificial tree. And what better tree to test drive than the Rolls Royce of artificial trees? The highly coveted Balsam Hill Christmas Tree.

If you had told me even five years ago I would be turning down the option to bring a fresh Fraser fir or sappy blue spruce into my home upstate, I would have laughed right in your face. Oh, how things change.

The Realism

The tree I chose is the BH Balsam Fir Flip Tree. That’s right – if I’m going artificial, I’m going to do it right. I want something that not only looks real but is really easy, too.

There are three levels of realism for Balsam Hill Christmas trees:

• Traditional: These are the types of trees most people are familiar with. This style is generally more cost-effective, and Balsam Hill uses 100% polyvinyl chloride (PVC) to create what it calls “Classic Needle” foliage.
• Realistic: Balsam Hill’s Realistic trees use up to 65% polyethylene (PE) to create what the brand calls “True Needle” foliage. The remainder of the tree foliage is Classic Needle, mostly on the interior and close to the bottom, which helps achieve the realism you want with the budget you have.
• Most Realistic: When you think of Balsam Hill, these are the trees that come to mind. These trees use more than 65% True Needle foliage for outstanding realism, with Classic Needles deeper in the tree near the trunk to add fullness and depth.

If you aren’t sure where to start, it’s OK. I wasn’t quite sure either. Given this is what Balsam Hill is known for, it should be no surprise that it has a comprehensive, easy-to-use guide on how to pick a tree.

When perusing the Balsam Hill website, the 7.5-foot pre-lit Balsam Fir Flip Tree, which falls within the “Most Realistic” category, seemed absolutely perfect.

My Tree Delivery

In my line of work, I get a lot of packages. This means I have the pleasure of getting to know my FedEx delivery person.

“What’s in here!? A person?” he asked, dragging the coffin-sized box across my front lawn as I opened my front door. With delight, I replied: “My new Christmas tree!”

It was clear from the start that this wouldn’t be some rinky-dink bargain-basement artificial Christmas tree that would instantly make me regret my decision. I got the box inside and took a step back – this would be a serious endeavor. I couldn’t wait to open it up and see it in all its glory.

The Set Up

The setup was surprisingly easy. I started by rolling the sophisticatedly secured tree out of the box. I was delivered upright, so all that was required was releasing the clasp that held the bagged tree sturdy and in place.

Once I had the tree out of the box and where I wanted it, I quickly ripped open the velcro to reveal what appeared to be a broken Christmas tree. It seemed much wider at the top than the bottom, and the wire arms and Classic needles gave me fake tree vibes.

Before I went further, I watched the easy setup YouTube video. I did not believe it would be as easy as the minute-and-a-half video insisted it would be. So when it was actually that easy, I was gobsmacked.

As instructed, I locked the wheels and put my foot on the side of the tree stand stated in the video and very quickly and easily flipped the tree over. Now, those traditional artificial tree branches acting as filler deep within the bottom of the tree all but disappeared beneath hyperrealistic fir branches.

So, there’s half the tree; where’s the rest, you ask? Packaged carefully in its own Rudolph red velcro bag specially designed to keep the top portion of the tree safe and shaped.

I opened the smaller bag with another rip of velcro and quickly inserted its trunk into the opening of the base, and that was it. I got a pre-lit tree, which required the additional step of connecting the power when connecting the top and base, but after that, I was just about done.

The Zhuzhing

The last step, which is more so for first-timers, is to fluff and shape the tree into an organic appearance that reflects the realistic look of the full greenery. In case you’re wondering, Balsam Hill also accounted for that by including not one, but two pairs of gloves that make digging deep in the branches to shape them without worrying about getting poked by sharp “needles.”

Taking It Down

Well, if I thought putting this tree up was easy, I was in for a treat when it came to taking it down. Sadly, we laypeople still need to take all the ornaments off and pack them in our coordinated Ornament Storage Boxes, Holiday Rubbermaid bins, and other creative storage containers.

However, once that part of the breakdown is complete, forget about dealing with unruly strings of lights, dry, sharp needles, or dumping gloopy water. This tree costs a premium for a reason. The design removes the actual work from having a tree so that all you have to do is enjoy it.

Unplug the single string of lights, remove the top third of the tree and place it in the red velcro bag (or this handy rolling Christmas tree storage box). Next, unlock the base wheels and give a good thrust – like magic, it flips upside down and assumes its at-ease position until next year.

The one element that was a little tricky – I hesitate even to go as far as to say difficult – was getting the big red bag wrapped and velcroed around the base of the tree. Once it has been shaped and fluffed up enough for celebration, it doesn’t want to fit in the bag as well as before.

Pros and Cons of my Balsam Hill Tree

My Balsam Hill Tree Verdict

If you are in the market for an artificial Christmas tree, I highly recommend you start with the best there is — Balsam Hill trees.

Decorating this lifelike tree makes me feel like I have been accepted to a Christmas club I didn’t know I needed. I’m looking forward to plugging in my favorite Bath and Body Works Fresh Balsam Wallflower (you heard me – they’re the best), lighting a fire, and cuddling up on the couch for a long winter’s night.

It’s easy to say that it doesn’t matter how realistic your Christmas tree looks, but once you have another cheap plastic tree, it will look like another cheap plastic tree, and those just don’t look nearly as good or last nearly as long as a durable tree built with future family festivities in mind. If you’re looking for a cheap throwaway tree, keep looking. However, if you’re looking for the last tree, you’ll ever need to buy, welcome to the club.

Best Balsam Hill Christmas Trees

The Balsam Hill tree that’s right for you largely depends on your budget. Trees within the Most Realistic category range from $349 to nearly $10,000. Realistic trees start from $499 and reach $11,000. Traditional-style trees start at $299 to $3,200.

Although sometimes you can snag a Balsam Hill on sale, the brand is offering a sure thing right now with a Balsam Hill coupon code. It’s good until September 30, 2024, when you buy directly from its site:

• $15 off orders of $350 or more with code BALSAMHILL15
• $20 off orders of $500 or more with code BALSAMHILL20
• $25 off orders of $600 or more with code BALSAMHILL30
• $40 off orders of $1,100 or more with code BALSAMHILL40
• $50 off orders of $1,500 or more with code 50BALSAMHILL
• $90 off orders of $2,100 or more with code BALSAMHILL90

Now, talk about Balsam Hill discount codes, but hurry, y’all; they expire soon.

Something to keep in mind is that the taller the tree, the more costly it will be. Some of Balsam Hill’s Realistic and Most Realistic trees can reach 18 feet tall, while Traditional trees top out at 15 feet.

Additionally, elements such as lights and the proprietary flip design of some trees add to the cost. However, there is no need to feel like you’ll have to spend three months’ mortgage to afford one artificial (looking) Christmas tree. Plenty of quality trees at an average height of 7 to 7.5 feet, from Traditional to Most Realistic, come in under $1,000.

I found six of the best Balsam Hill Artificial Christmas trees under $1,000:

Specs: Height: 6.5 feet | Shape: Full tree | Tree type: Classic Blue Spruce | Weight: 50.4 pounds | Color: Green | Lights: Clear lights | Stand included

---

Specs: Height: 7 Feet | Shape: Full tree | Tree: Vancouver Spruce | Color: Green | Lights: Clear lights | Includes tree stand

---

Specs: Height: 7 Feet | Shape: Full tree | Tree type: Pine | Lights: LED clear lights | Color: Frosted sugar pine trees | Includes tree stand

---

Specs: Height: 6.5 Feet | Shape: Slim tree | Tree type: Berkshire | Lights: LED clear lights | Color: Green | Includes tree stand

---

Specs: Height: 7 feet | Shape: Full tree | Tree type: Spruce | Lights: Clear LED lights or unlit | Tree stand included

---

Specs: Height: 6.5 Feet | Shape: Slim tree | Tree type: Spruce | Lights: Multi-colored LED lights or green unlit | Color: Green | Includes tree stand

---

Specs: Height: 6.5 Feet | Shape: Sparse tree | Tree type: n/a | Lights: LED clear fairy lights | Color: Green | Includes tree stand

---

Specs: Height: 6.5 feet and 7.5 feet | Shape: Stratford | Tree type: Spruce | Lights: Unlit | Color: Green | Includes tree stand

---

Check out New York Post Shopping for more content.

---

For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.

---